One of the most eye-catching and enigmatic entrances in America’s Got Talent history was made by Sydney, Australia-based performer Sheldon Riley. At first, Sheldon remained silent and kept his face hidden behind an ornate, glittering mask and expensive, avant-garde attire, allowing his voice and artistic abilities to speak for themselves. His song of Billie Eilish’s “idontwannabeyouanymore” was hauntingly beautiful and deep, displaying a vocal range and emotional depth that left the judges and the crowd in complete wonder.
Sheldon eventually spoke after his performance, stating that his appearance was a means of expressing his love of music and fashion as well as finding confidence. He disclosed that as a child, he had trouble fitting in and believed that people didn’t notice him until he adopted his distinct style. Because he believed that the US was a country where “different” is not only welcomed but also celebrated, he made the long journey from Australia to the American stage. Sheldon acknowledged that he had previously shied away from significant opportunities, demonstrating that his vulnerability was every bit as potent as his singing.
All of the judges praised Sheldon, with Simon Cowell praising his uniqueness and enigmatic character as a welcome change. His “Cleopatra eyes” were praised by Sofia Vergara, who also pointed out that his talent was evident despite the disguise. Sheldon clarified that his intention was to encourage young children to be fearlessly authentic. Sheldon Riley advanced to the next round as one of the most talked-about acts of the season after receiving three ecstatic “yeses,” demonstrating that genuine talent cannot be concealed, not even by a mask.
